Bill Morgan Asks: Has Ripple Opened Another Legal Portal with This Settlement?

The post Bill Morgan Asks: Has Ripple Opened Another Legal Portal with This Settlement? appeared first on Coinpedia Fintech News The courtroom drama between Ripple Labs and the U.S. SEC took another unexpected turn as Judge Analisa Torres denied a joint request from both parties due to a procedural misstep. Although Ripple and the SEC were close to settling, they used the wrong legal rule in their filing. This mistake now sends them back to fix it, and legal expert Bill Morgan says it could seriously affect the whole settlement. Ripple has now officially asked the court for an indicative ruling under Rule 62.1 and relief from final judgment under Rule 60(b). A Breakdown in Legal Strategy The questions that I am reflecting on following the latest decision yesterday of Judge Torres are as follows: 1. whether the parties can file another motion under Fed.R.Civ.P 60 pursuant to the terms off settlement agreement. 2.whether this needs another vote of the five… — bill morgan (@Belisarius2020) May 16, 2025 Morgan highlighted that the original settlement agreement referenced Rule 62.1, which allows courts to provide an indicative ruling when a case is on appeal. However, before that, you must understand what it all means. Rule 60 is for asking a judge to change or cancel a final judgment. It’s used when both sides want to undo something the court has already decided. Rule 62.1 is for when the case is already on appeal — the judge can’t act, but can say what they would do if the case came back. In the present scenario, with Judge Torres denying that motion, the question becomes whether Ripple and the SEC can now pivot and refile under Rule 60, which permits a court to relieve a party from a final judgment under exceptional circumstances. Complications with SEC Approval How the settlement process is going 1. Settlement agreement signed by Ripple parties on April 23, 2025 and by the SEC on May 8, 2025 . 2. Parties filed a motion to hold the appeal and cross appeal in abeyance 3. Parties file rule 62.1 motion asking for an indicative… — bill morgan (@Belisarius2020) May 16, 2025 One of the most important issues Morgan pointed out is whether a new motion under Rule 60 would require another vote from the five SEC commissioners. The previous vote specifically approved a process using Rule 62.1. If the legal path changes, Morgan suggests it’s unclear whether the original vote still holds or if a fresh round of approval is needed from the commission. .article-inside-link { margin-left: 0 !important; border: 1px solid #0052CC4D; border-left: 0; border-right: 0; padding: 10px 0; text-align: left; } .entry ul.article-inside-link li { font-size: 14px; line-height: 21px; font-weight: 600; list-style-type: none; margin-bottom: 0; display: inline-block; } .entry ul.article-inside-link li:last-child { display: none; } Also Read : Why XRP Price Is Down Today? , Uncertainty Around the Settlement’s Validity Morgan also questions whether the failure to get an indicative ruling under Rule 62.1 fundamentally disrupts the settlement. While the agreement’s operative clauses are tied to the recitals, which describe the overall terms, there’s no clear backup plan in the event the Rule 62.1 motion fails. Moreover, this raises doubts about whether the settlement can proceed at all without rewriting or renegotiating key parts. Did They Really Miss This? Lastly, Morgan doubts that experienced attorneys on both sides simply forgot about Rule 60. He suggests they may have chosen Rule 62.1 on purpose to avoid the tougher task of proving “exceptional circumstances,” which Rule 60 demands. In short, while Ripple and the SEC seem ready to move toward settlement , Judge Torres has made it clear they must follow the rules closely, and that could complicate the road ahead. .article_register_shortcode { padding: 18px 24px; border-radius: 8px; display: flex; align-items: center; margin: 6px 0 22px; border: 1px solid #0052CC4D; background: linear-gradient(90deg, rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.1) 0%, rgba(0, 82, 204, 0.1) 100%); } .article_register_shortcode .media-body h5 { color: #000000; font-weight: 600; font-size: 20px; line-height: 22px; text-align:left; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body h5 span { color: #0052CC; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body p { font-weight: 400; font-size: 14px; line-height: 22px; color: #171717B2; margin-top: 4px; text-align:left; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body{ padding-right: 14px; } .article_register_shortcode .media-button a { float: right; } .article_register_shortcode .primary-button img{ vertical-align: middle; width: 20px; margin: 0; display: inline-block; } @media (min-width: 581px) and (max-width: 991px) { .article_register_shortcode .media-body p { margin-bottom: 0; } } @media (max-width: 580px) { .article_register_shortcode { display: block; padding: 20px; } .article_register_shortcode img { max-width: 50px; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body h5 { font-size: 16px; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body { margin-left: 0px; } .article_register_shortcode .media-body p { font-size: 13px; line-height: 20px; margin-top: 6px; margin-bottom: 14px; } .article_register_shortcode .media-button a { float: unset; } .article_register_shortcode .secondary-button { margin-bottom: 0; } } Never Miss a Beat in the Crypto World! Stay ahead with breaking news, expert analysis, and real-time updates on the latest trends in Bitcoin, altcoins, DeFi, NFTs, and more. .subscription-options li { display: none; } .research-report-subscribe{ background-color: #0052CC; padding: 12px 20px; border-radius: 8px; color: #fff; font-weight: 500; font-size: 14px; width: 96%; } .research-report-subscribe img{ vertical-align: sub; margin-right: 2px; } Subscribe to News var templateIds = “6”; var listOfSubscribed = []; function subscribed_popupmodal(template_id) { var templateId = ‘6’; getAllSubscriberCategoryList([templateId]); var subcribemodal = window.parent.document.getElementById(‘subscribe-modal-design’); if (subcribemodal) { var modalContent = ` Never Miss a Beat in the Crypto World! Stay informed and gain the edge you need to navigate the crypto world. Select your subscription now Daily Get real-time crypto news, market insights, and blockchain updates. Weekly Stay updated with major trends, funding news, and price analysis. Monthly Receive a detailed report with market analysis and expert predictions. Subscribe Now `; subcribemodal.innerHTML = modalContent; } subscribe_unsubscribe_status(template_id); //getAllSubscriberCategoryList(template_id); } function toggleSubscription(subscription, template_id) { var subscriptionCheckbox = document.getElementById(subscription + ‘_’ + template_id); var li = document.getElementById(subscription + ‘Selected_’ + template_id); if (subscriptionCheckbox.checked) { li.classList.add(‘active’); } else { li.classList.remove(‘active’); } } function getAllSubscriberCategoryList(getcategoryId) { jQuery.ajax({ url: ‘https://coinpedia.org/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php’, type: ‘GET’, data: { action: ‘subscribe_api_ajax_request’, apiurl: ‘/app/email_newsletter/list’, }, success: function(response) { var result = JSON.parse(response.message); if (result.status === true) { var idstosubscribed = [] // Populate listOfSubscribed with subscribed category IDs result.message.forEach(listofcategory => { if (listofcategory.subscribe_status === 1) { if (!listOfSubscribed.includes(listofcategory._id)) { listOfSubscribed.push(listofcategory._id); } if (!idstosubscribed.includes(listofcategory.news_cp_category_row_id)) { idstosubscribed.push(listofcategory.news_cp_category_row_id); } } }); idstosubscribed.forEach(id => { var subscribeButton = document.getElementById(‘subscribe_’ + id); var unsubscribeButton = document.getElementById(‘unsubscribe_’ + id); if (subscribeButton && unsubscribeButton) { subscribeButton.style.display = ‘none’; unsubscribeButton.style.display = ‘block’; var showDownloadReport = document.getElementById(‘download_report’); if (showDownloadReport) { showDownloadReport.style.display = ‘block’; } } }); } }, error: function(xhr, status, error) { console.error(‘Error:’, error); } }); } function subscribe_unsubscribe_status(getcategoryId) { var elementTounsubscribe = parent.document.getElementById(‘unsubscribe_’ + getcategoryId); var elementTosubscribe = parent.document.getElementById(‘subscribe_’ + getcategoryId); jQuery.ajax({ url: ‘https://coinpedia.org/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php’, type: ‘POST’, data: { action: ‘subscribe_api_ajax_request’, apiurl: ‘/app/email_newsletter/list?category_row_id=’ + getcategoryId, }, success: function(response) { var result = JSON.parse(response.message); if (result.status === true) { parent.jQuery(‘.skeliton-loader-block’).hide(); var hasSubscribeStatusOne = false; result.message.forEach(subscribeStatus => { if (listOfSubscribed.includes(subscribeStatus._id) && subscribeStatus.subscribe_status === 1) { hasSubscribeStatusOne = true; } if (subscribeStatus.notification_type === 3) { parent.document.getElementById(‘monthlySelected_’ + getcategoryId).style.display = ‘block’; parent.document.getElementById(‘monthly_’ + getcategoryId).setAttribute(‘data-id’, subscribeStatus._id); if (subscribeStatus.subscribe_status === 1) { parent.document.getElementById(‘monthly_’ + getcategoryId).checked = true; } } else if (subscribeStatus.notification_type === 2) { parent.document.getElementById(‘weeklySelected_’ + getcategoryId).style.display = ‘block’; parent.document.getElementById(‘weekly_’ + getcategoryId).setAttribute(‘data-id’, subscribeStatus._id); if (subscribeStatus.subscribe_status === 1) { parent.document.getElementById(‘weekly_’ + getcategoryId).checked = true; } } else if (subscribeStatus.notification_type === 1) { parent.document.getElementById(‘dailySelected_’ + getcategoryId).style.display = ‘block’; parent.document.getElementById(‘daily_’ + getcategoryId).setAttribute(‘data-id’, subscribeStatus._id); if (subscribeStatus.subscribe_status === 1) { parent.document.getElementById(‘daily_’ + getcategoryId).checked = true; } } if (subscribeStatus.subscribe_status === 1) { listOfSubscribed.push(subscribeStatus._id); } }); if (hasSubscribeStatusOne) { elementTosubscribe.style.display = ‘none’; elementTounsubscribe.style.display = ‘block’; } else { elementTosubscribe.style.display = ‘block’; elementTounsubscribe.style.display = ‘none’; } } }, error: function(xhr, status, error) { console.error(‘Error:’, error); } }); } function logSelectedSubscriptions(categoryid) { var unsubscribemodal = document.querySelector(‘.unsubscribed-popup-modal .modal’); var subscribedmodal = document.querySelector(‘.subscribed-popup-modal .modal’); unsubscribemodal.innerHTML=”; subscribedmodal.innerHTML=”; var selectedSubscriptions = []; var storeCheckedId = []; var checkboxes = document.querySelectorAll(‘#subscription-options-‘ + categoryid + ‘ input[type=”checkbox”]’); var errorMessage = document.getElementById(‘error-message-select’); // Use a Set to handle unique data-ids var uniqueSubscribedIds = new Set(listOfSubscribed); checkboxes.forEach(function(checkbox) { var dataId = parseInt(checkbox.getAttribute(‘data-id’)); if (checkbox.checked) { selectedSubscriptions.push(checkbox.id); storeCheckedId.push(dataId); } else { uniqueSubscribedIds.delete(dataId); // Remove unchecked data-id } }); // Update listOfSubscribed with unique values listOfSubscribed = Array.from(uniqueSubscribedIds); var selectedSubscriptionsString = selectedSubscriptions.join(‘, ‘); var concatinateSubscribeId = […new Set(storeCheckedId.concat(listOfSubscribed))]; var categoryData = { ‘subscribed_categories’: concatinateSubscribeId }; var requestSubscriberData = { action: ‘handle_dynamic_api_request_with_headers’, security: ’81e1ca5091′, endpoint: ‘/app/email_newsletter/update_categories’, token: ”, data: categoryData }; jQuery.ajax({ url: ‘https://coinpedia.org/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php’, type: ‘POST’, data: requestSubscriberData, beforeSend: function(xhr) { xhr.setRequestHeader(‘X-Requested-With’, ‘XMLHttpRequest’); }, success: function(response) { try { response = response.data; if (storeCheckedId.length === 0) { var unsubcribedPopUpmodal = ` You’ve Unsubscribed Successfully We’re sorry to see you go! Your subscription has been canceled. If you change your mind, you can re-subscribe anytime. Thank you for being part of our community! `; unsubscribemodal.innerHTML = unsubcribedPopUpmodal; document.querySelector(‘#subscribe-modal-design .modal’).style.display = ‘none’; unsubscribemodal.style.display = ‘block’; unsubscribemodal.classList.remove(‘hide’); unsubscribemodal.classList.add(‘show’); document.getElementById(‘subscribe_’ + categoryid).style.display = ‘block’; document.getElementById(‘unsubscribe_’ + categoryid).style.display = ‘none’; var showDownloadReport = document.getElementById(‘download_report’); if (showDownloadReport) { showDownloadReport.style.display = ‘none’; } } else { var subscribedPopupModal = ` Thank you for subscribing! Thank you for subscribing to our crypto and blockchain newsletter! You’ll now receive the latest news, insights, and updates straight to your inbox. Welcome to our community! `; let selectedSubscriptionsArray = selectedSubscriptionsString.split(‘,’); let subscribedCategories = selectedSubscriptionsArray.map(subscription => subscription.split(‘_’)[0]); let subscribedCategoriesString = subscribedCategories.join(‘, ‘); subscribedmodal.innerHTML = subscribedPopupModal; if (document.getElementById(‘selectidname’)) { document.getElementById(‘selectidname’).textContent = subscribedCategoriesString; } document.querySelector(‘#subscribe-modal-design .modal’).style.display = ‘none’; subscribedmodal.style.display = ‘block’; subscribedmodal.classList.remove(‘hide’); subscribedmodal.classList.add(‘show’); document.getElementById(‘subscribe_’ + categoryid).style.display = ‘none’; document.getElementById(‘unsubscribe_’ + categoryid).style.display = ‘block’; var showDownloadReport = document.getElementById(‘download_report’); if (showDownloadReport) { showDownloadReport.style.display = ‘block’; } } } catch (e) { console.error(‘Error parsing response:’, e); } }, }); } function closeModal(template_id) { var modalId = template_id; var modal = document.querySelector(‘#’ + modalId); // Using querySelector to find the modal if (modal) { modal.classList.add(‘hide’); modal.classList.remove(‘show’); setTimeout(function() { modal.style.display = ‘none’; }, 500); } else { console.warn(‘Modal not found:’, modalId); } } function closeunsubscribemodal() { var unsubscribemodal = document.querySelector(‘.unsubscribed-popup-modal .modal’); if (unsubscribemodal) { unsubscribemodal.classList.add(‘hide’); unsubscribemodal.classList.remove(‘show’); } setTimeout(function() { unsubscribemodal.style.display = ‘none’; }, 500); } function closesubscribemodal() { var subscribedmodal = document.querySelector(‘.subscribed-popup-modal .modal’); setTimeout(function() { subscribedmodal.style.display = ‘none’; }, 500); if (subscribedmodal) { subscribedmodal.classList.add(‘hide’); subscribedmodal.classList.remove(‘show’); } } function withoutLoginClicked(withoutlogin_id) { localStorage.setItem(‘subscribe_without_Login’, ‘true’); localStorage.setItem(‘subscribe_clicked_id’, withoutlogin_id); } document.addEventListener(‘DOMContentLoaded’, function() { const subscribewithoutData = localStorage.getItem(‘subscribe_without_Login’); const subscribe_clicked_cat_id = localStorage.getItem(‘subscribe_clicked_id’); // Function to get cookies function getCookie(name) { let value = “; ” + document.cookie; let parts = value.split(“; ” + name + “=”); if (parts.length == 2) return parts.pop().split(“;”).shift(); } // Get user token from cookies const userToken = getCookie(‘user_token’); if (subscribewithoutData === ‘true’ && userToken) { // Call the modal function with the category ID subscribed_popupmodal(subscribe_clicked_cat_id); // Remove the flag and category ID from localStorage localStorage.removeItem(‘subscribe_without_Login’); localStorage.removeItem(‘subscribe_clicked_id’); } }); /************************** update susbcriber content **************************** */ function initializeSubscriptionButton() { var initialListItems = document.querySelectorAll(‘.subscription-options input[type=”checkbox”]’); initialListItems.forEach(function(item) { console.log(item.checked, ‘Initial Checkbox checked status’); }); var listItems = document.querySelectorAll(‘.subscription-options li’); if (listItems.length === 0) return; var anyActive = false; listItems.forEach(function(item) { var checkbox = item.querySelector(‘input[type=”checkbox”]’); if (checkbox) { if (checkbox.checked) { item.classList.add(‘active’); anyActive = true; // Set anyActive to true } else { item.classList.remove(‘active’); // Remove ‘active’ class if checkbox is unchecked } } }); } function updateButtonText(anyActive) { var subscribeButtonSpan = document.querySelector(‘.subscribe-submit .changeBtnText’); if (subscribeButtonSpan) { if (anyActive) { subscribeButtonSpan.textContent = ‘Subscribe Now’; } else { subscribeButtonSpan.textContent = ‘Unsubscribe’; } } } function updateSubscriptionButton() { var listItems = document.querySelectorAll(‘.subscription-options li’); if (listItems.length === 0) return; var anyActive = false; listItems.forEach(function(item) { var checkbox = item.querySelector(‘input[type=”checkbox”]’); if (checkbox) { if (checkbox.checked) { item.classList.add(‘active’); anyActive = true; // Set anyActive to true } else { item.classList.remove(‘active’); // Remove ‘active’ class if checkbox is unchecked } } }); // Update the button text based on whether any list item has the ‘active’ class updateButtonText(anyActive); } document.addEventListener(‘click’, function(event) { var clickedItem = event.target.closest(‘.subscription-options li’); if (clickedItem) { var checkbox = clickedItem.querySelector(‘input[type=”checkbox”]’); if (checkbox) { checkbox.checked = !checkbox.checked; updateSubscriptionButton(); } } }); FAQs Does Ripple need new SEC approval to refile under Rule 60(b)? Possibly. Since the SEC originally approved using Rule 62.1, a Rule 60 refiling might need a fresh commissioner vote. Is the Ripple and SEC settlement at risk now? Yes, the failed motion under Rule 62.1 may force renegotiation or delay the settlement entirely.

Source: coinpedia